Waiting Time is Often Work Time . . . and Must be Paid

A Tennessee car wash found out the hard way that “waiting time”—time employees spend between tasks—is paid working time. Employees of the Shur-Brite car wash in Nashville sued claiming that the car wash would clock the workers in and out multiple times a day—clocking them in when a car pulled in to be washed, clocking them out when there were no cars around.

An advocate for low-wage earners went undercover at Shur-Brite and was clocked out more than 10 times during a single eight-hour shift. The result—he was paid for only four of the eight hours. The case settled for $130,000.00.

Continue Reading...

On-Call Time: To Pay or Not to Pay?

With new technology such as BlackBerries®, cellphones, etc., the practice of requiring employees to be available on call is becoming even more widespread. Now, not only are healthcare and emergency workers required to be on call, but workers in many other industries are also expected to be available 24/7. AT&T workers in California just joined together to bring a class action, filed August 12, 2009 in the Southern District of California, claiming that they should have been paid for being on call 24/7 to handle IT maintenance services for customers’ hardware, software, applications and desktop computers. 

What constitutes “on-call” time that is deemed to be work requiring compensation? The Wage and Hour Division of the Department of Labor issued a letter earlier this year (see) explaining some of the criteria:  

“Under 29 C.F.R. § 785.17, ‘[a]n employee who is required to remain on call on the employer’s premises or so close thereto that he cannot use the time effectively for his own purposes is working while “on call.” An employee who is not required to remain on the employer’s premises but is merely required to leave word at his home or with company officials where he may be reached is not working while on call.’”  

Some of the key issues to consider in determining whether to pay for on-call time are: 

  • Is the employee required to stay at home or required only to carry a cellphone or other device to receive calls?
  • How close to the work location (whether it be the company office or a customer location) is the employee required to be? In other words, what is the required response time?
  • Are employees on call 24/7, or only certain hours per week or month, and can they switch their on-call time with colleagues if necessary for their personal purposes?
  • Does the “on-call” obligation significantly limit the employee’s use of the time for personal purposes?
  • How frequent are the calls? Are the calls likely to occupy most of the on-call time and will being on call therefore significantly interfere with the employee’s use of the time for personal purposes? Or are the calls only infrequent?
  • Is the employee required to wear a uniform while on call?

Based on these criteria, if it is determined that the on-call time constitutes work, non-exempt employees must be compensated for all of the on-call time in accordance with the standard rates and laws for regular and overtime pay. Additionally, even if the on-call time is not considered to be work requiring compensation, any time in which an employee actually does perform work in responding to a call must be compensated.